Celebrating the Unpopular Arts
 

Alternative timelines in Christian film

(A rewritten post from my own blog) One of the things I learned writing Now and Then We Time Travel is that everyone is fascinated by the idea of time travel and its subgenres.

There are French, Italian, Russian, Chinese, Japanese, German and Australian time-travel films and TV series. There are movies that use time travel as a deus ex machina at the very end to solve the protagonist’s problems. And there are at least a half-dozen Christian time-travel movies — quite possibly more, as Christian films aren’t always easy to keep track of (I stumbled across one not long after I’d finished the book, darn it). This post is about two Christian movies with an alternate history theme. What If … (2010) was amiably forgettable, Doonby (2013) was memorable but not in a good way.

Do any of you remember Family Man (2000)? That film has corporate shark Nicolas Cage learn what would have happened if he and his sweetheart (Tea Leoni) had kept their promise to marry after college. What If has the identical concept with a weaker cast, Kevin Sorbo as the ruthless shark and Kristy Swanson as his lost love. It also lifts way too many specific scenes from the earlier film rather than just the core concept (which has been borrowed multiple times). The opening scene where the couple split up, for instance, is way too close for coincidence.

The Christian aspect does add some new wrinkles though. Cage’s character was merely selfish; Ben’s (Sorbo) decision went against God’s divine plan for his life. His original dream with Wendy (Swanson) wasn’t simply marriage but founding a ministry together. Then there’s a scene where Ben finally accepts his duties as a godly father: knowing his daughter has the hots for a boy, he meets him and arranges their first date, though chaperoned and according to Ben, technically not a date (dating has a very negative connotation in some sectors of conservative Christianity). I already knew that some Christians consider this approach a wise godly one; watching it on screen, I find it creepy as hell.

One problem I had with Family Man is that after spending the entire movie with Cage’s alt.family and kids, they’re apparently wiped out of existence when the timeline resets. I’m apparently not the only one bugged by that: What If has Ben raise the question of what happened to his daughters. Heavenly mentor Mike (John Ratzenberger) assures him they will come into existence, just later in this timeline.

My research viewing for almost every one of my film books includes some movies that don’t fit. That’s because it’s not always possible to decide that until I watch them. If I skip something that doesn’t sound like a good candidate I save time, but I could end up missing something like Doonby.

John Schneider plays Sam Doonby, a vagabond whose arrival in a small Southern town gets all the young women palpitating with excitement, particularly barmaid Jolene (Brandi Blevins) and Laura Reaper (Jenn Gotzon), spoiled daughter of the town ob/gyn (Joe Estevez). Sam goes to work as a bartender, starts dating Laura and becomes the very man the town needs: he saves his boss (Ernie Hudson) from an armed robber, snatches a kid from the path of a truck, rescues Laura from a knife-wielding stalker and saves Dr. Reaper from the ultimate menace — a slut crying rape! Jolene, you see, didn’t appreciate Laura winning Sam’s affection so she accuses her father out of spite (why not accuse Sam? Plot reasons, as you’ll see). False rape accusations aren’t any more common than false accusations of other crimes but they loom a lot larger in pop culture, and in the right-wing worldview.

Watching the film, I began to wonder if Doonby was a time traveler, sent back to avert all these disasters. I mean, isn’t it a little implausible that he showed up in town just when he’s needed? The local sheriff (Robert Davi) begins wondering the same thing but comes to a different conclusion: maybe Sam’s setting all this up somehow so he can be a hero. Laura, how much do you really know about your boyfriend?

Laura initially dismisses this talk but over time it gnaws at her. Finally she snaps and they have a big argument where she accuses Sam of cheating on her with Jolene. Sam denies it, she refuses to believe him and tells him she wishes he’d never come to town.

Presto, he didn’t!

The movie, it turns out, is a reverse It’s a Wonderful Life:  the world in which Sam saves everyone is the alternative timeline, the real world is the one in which he didn’t exist … BECAUSE DR. REAPER ABORTED HIM YEARS AGO! OMG! Once Laura rejects Sam she finds herself back in the original timeline: everyone he saved his dead and Jolene’s accusations destroyed her father’s career, leaving him a pathetic drunk—OMG again! And then Laura realizes, in the soul-shattering finish, that “Doonby” is an anagram for … nobody. Because thanks to her, he is nobody now, get it? OMG once more! And if that isn’t shocking enough, think about this: calling the doctor “reaper” is a dark pun because he killed a baby!!!! (That’s not my view of abortion but the filmmakers have their own opinion).

For most of the running time, the film is competently made (trust me, I’ve watched worse), albeit unexciting. The ending, however, is gibberish. If Sam didn’t save anyone, why didn’t Laura’s stalker kill her? Why would Jolene accuse Reaper of rape when there’s no need to punish Laura? What exactly was God’s purpose in bringing Sam back to life? In It’s a Wonderful Life, Clarence the Angel intervenes to stop a good man from killing himself; when George realizes how much he loves his life, the alternative world ends. That doesn’t work here, where Sam Doonby could have easily grown up to break legs for the mob. The whole premise feels less like God and more like a deal-with-the-devil story: “If you can get the daughter of the man who killed you to love you, you live! If she rejects you, it’s back to nonexistence!”

And why is Laura the only one who remembers Earth-Doonby? I can understand the need to have her show the audience the moral (Abortion is Bad! Very, Very Bad!) but the burden of knowing what could have been is a cruel one; it’s hard to see how she deserves it.

One comment

  1. Gavin

    Has anyone ever done one of these where the aborted kid would have been a serial killer? I suppose all those “prevent Hitler from being born” stories cover that, though without the religious overtones.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.