Writing about my indexing efforts on Watching Jekyll and Hyde got me thinking about how much of what we imagine is the “right” way to organize things — indexes, alphabetical order — is not as intuitively obvious as it feels. As the two books I’m writing about here (reposted from my own blog) show.
It seems obvious that prioritizing letters and using alphabetical order is a sensible structure for any catalog or index but Judith Flanders’ A Place for Everything: The Curious History of Alphabetical Order details how alphabetical arrangements are a relatively novel approach.
Alphabetical order, after all, is arbitrary: the entries that start with AA are just as good as those that begin with ZZ. For our ancestors, that was a drawback: the classification should reflect status and importance. A medieval monastery, for example, would start its catalog with books of the Bible, then works of great Christian thinkers. Then great pagan philosophers like Aristotle. Finally, after all the other categories, you’d get to things like Brother Andrew’s pamphlet on the Book of Isaiah. The tax collector’s office would start with a list of the richest tax payers, then work its way down to the poorest.
Some collectors and institutions developed a unique system that made sense to them. That usually worked perfectly … until someone else inherited it and had to figure it out. I went through this myself with my own collection. At one time I had the Flashing Swords sword-and-sorcery anthologies sharing a shelf with the authors who appeared in the series. Then as I acquired other anthologies I put them next to Flashing Swords … and the end result was a long stretch of anthologies, then authors who sat on the shelf apparently at random. Eventually I went with alphabetical order.
Flanders also points out that even though alphabetical order is random — AJQBCM makes just as much sense as ABCDEF — we all “know” the proper order and that makes it no longer so arbitrary: an A-lister is better than a D-lister, a B-movie isn’t as good as an A-movie. She also speculates that search engines may change the game again, as they free us from searching alphabetically.
Index, A History of The: A Bookish Adventure from Medieval Manuscripts to the Digital Age by Dennis Duncan shows that the
methods for indexing aren’t intuitive either. Back in the days before page numbers, an author might have indexed by chapters or quartos. Writing a good index takes some judgment: if you have a hundred pages dealing with Winston Churchill, simply writing “Churchill, Winston” and listing the pages won’t help someone looking for a specific detail. Then again, a detailed listing of sub-entries covering different parts of his life can bog readers down. For a book like mine, all the different Dr. Jekyll and Hyde movies have to be listed separately with some sort of identifier. Typically that’s a date like “1920 film” or “1931 film” and if that isn’t enough, I add the movie studio (there were three different same-name films in 1920, for instance). Duncan also covers satirical indexes and concerns indexing was just a short cut for lazy readers — flip through the index, memorize some key names and you can bluff that you’ve read the book.
Covers by Neal Adams (top) and Bob Brown.
